A Guide To Our Rankings: How We Picked our Top Choice

After and intense research, consultations with numerous customers interviewed, we found the following 3 products that became our top picks. We chose these three based on the following factors:

Evaluation Criteria

Ease of use

Affordability / Value 


Impressive results

Clearly labeled ingredients

Effective concentration percentage

Company Reputation

Here's How To Choose the Right One For You:

We all long for the fountain of youth. Looking good and feeling great has never been so accessible. Most people know collagen can really make a difference in our skin, hair, nails, and bones these days:

After the age of 25, our bodies produce less and less collagen every year. As a result, our skin begins to sag and develop fine lines. Our hair can become weak and brittle, and our joints can feel more achy and sore. That’s why more people are turning to collagen supplements. 

Collagen comes from the Greek word “glue,” because that’s essentially what it does. It keeps our body together in a meshed matrix of strands that form of cartilage, joints, skin, hair, and nails. So much of your body relies on this collagen matrix. If we don’t get enough of it we break down.

Did you know there are actually over 28 different types of collagen?

Every living animal has collagen, including marine life, birds, and mammals like cows. In each animal, like humans, they have various forms of collagen for different functions as well.

The Top 5 Collagen Supplements of 2022

Latest update: April 8, 2022

Best Overall

139 Hours Researched

3 Experts Consulted

20 customers Interviewed

Read Review

by Primal Harvest[1]

1834 Reviews

Primal Collagen

US made with Premium Ingredients

Packed With Amino Acids

Powerful GMO Free Collagen

Sourced from Grass-Fed Bovine

Free Shipping on Orders over $75

2,367 people chose this today

The Two Collagen Types Our Bodies Need Most

When it comes to supplements there are two types of collagen that are the most beneficial for our bodies. 

Type I - This is the most abundant collagen of the human body. It is present in scar tissue, the end product when tissue heals by repair. It is found in tendons, skin, artery walls, surrounding muscle fibers, and the organic part of bones and teeth.

Type III - This is the collagen of granulation tissue. It is found in artery walls, skin, intestines, and the uterus. Type III is the connective tissue, the collagen that is like mesh around the liver inside the liver that separates the different parts. It's more delicate, as in the bone marrow, and in the lymph.

Why We Need to Consume Collagen Supplements

Most people assume that if they eat enough animal protein they will get Collagen in their bodies. The truth is that even if you are eating a lot of meat, it would be very hard for your body to synthesize protein and rebuild it into Collagen. To build Collagen your body requires a lot more to link all the amino chains together. 

Using a Collagen Supplement helps you avoid consuming as much protein meat. It’s easier, cheaper, and more effective than shoving down impossible quantities of meat and plants to digest.

You get close to a 90% absorption rate with Collagen supplements, whereas, getting collagen from food it’s as low as 25-35%. Since most of us don’t eat like Gorillas, when we injure a joint, ligament, or tendon, it may feel like our joints aren’t recovering.

Which Type of Collagen is Best For You?

Bovine Collagen - The Best Collagen Source 

Naturally sourced from the hides of cattle, this kind is very high in collagen Types 1 and 3 and contains a high amount of protein. In fact, it contains almost double the amount found in marine collagenWith a large amount of glycine, bovine collagen is excellent for hair, skin, nails, as well as our connective tissues and digestive health. In most cases, bovine collagen will give you the best bang for your buck and is often called the fountain of youth collagen source.

What Kind? 


Type of Collagen?


Fish Scales And Skins

Type 1 only


Hides Of Cattle

Type 1 & Type 3


Sternum, Bones, & Cartilages

Type 2

The Good and The Bad: 

All Collagen Is NOT Created Equal

With over 300 various collagen supplements on the market, choosing the collagen that is right for you can seem like an uphill battle. When choosing a collagen supplement, always read labels, verify origins of ingredients, or research these important details before making your decision:

The Good - Certified, Accredited, Best Practices

Reputable companies will indicate with labels their certifying bodies as well as proper ingredients and manufacturing practices:

  • Gluten-Free, Allergen-Free, and Non - GMO
  • Dairy-Free, Pasture Raised, Lab Tested
  • Good Manufacturing Practice certified
  • Made in an FDA registered facility
  • Made in the USA
  • 3rd Party Certified - 100% Laboratory tested for purity and potency
  • Sourced From Grass-fed Beef (in the case of Bovine Collagen) - You won't find any antibiotics in grass-fed bovine collagen powder.  Just 100% premium quality Bovine (type I & III) Hydrolyzed Collagen Peptides.
  • Contains essential Amino Acid profile
  • Helps your current nutrition goals
  • Premium grade collagen
  • Mixes extremely well, best out of all competition
  • Tastes great or flavorless.

The Bad  - Poor Quality, Inconsistency, and Ineffectiveness

Some companies selling collagen do the right thing legally, but they simply have an inferior product, which will not help you, and will be a miserable experience fo you:

  • No potency - No Results. No effect whatsoever
  • Multi-Collagen blends  - Too General - Not focused on your essential needs
  • Not consistent - a totally different consistency with each order the granules are different sizes, too large, and not soft powder. The texture, solubility, and even the color are always different and clumpy in liquids of different temperatures
  • Horrible Taste - strange aftertaste…. Definitely not tasteless
  • Insoluble -  it does not dissolve and is harder to mix
  • Not complete - product to come half empty.

When choosing a collagen peptide, just reading the label and believing the marketing isn’t enough. There’s so much more to it.

Here at Smarter Choices, we use a proven 10-point ranking system to test and compare collagen peptide supplements. It’s important to know how our ranking system works:

Product quality and purity  based on ingredients and sourcing.


The presence/lack of artificial additives, preservatives and fillers.


Our Research-Backed 10-Point System

High-quality, regulated manufacturing facilities and processes.


Manufacturer FDA-Registration and GMP-certification.


Return policy and money back guarantee


The science, research and development behind the product.


The availability, digestibility and absorption of collagen delivered per serve.


Third-party testing to validate what’s on the label tells the truth.


Customer reviews – removing fake/paid reviews so only real opinion count.


Price and value for money


Top Collagen Supplements 2022

1. Primal Collagen

by Primal Harvest [1]


1533 votes


Ingredient Quality Control

Potency & Estimated Efficacy

Price / Customer Value

Return Policy

Overall Customer Happiness








Made in the USA with premium quality full spectrum collagen

"No questions asked" 90-day Money-Back-Guarantee

Unflavored, easiest to dissolve powder

Made from certified grass-fed and pasture-raised bovine

Only the purest bovine collagen with GelcoPEP® technology.

Diverse amino acid profile to boost your health and energy

Only Available Online

Sometimes runs out of Stock

The Bottom Line

Primal Collagen by Primal Harvest is a unique brand. Their collagen is sourced from grass-fed, pasture-raised bovine. This enables it to provide key collagen types I and III in a highly absorbable form. These immediately work at the cellular level to support healthy hair, skin, nails, joints, bones, and gut. 

The company has harnessed a unique technology to get these results. This technology is called GelcoPEP®. This formula dissolves quickly making it convenient to stir into any liquid of your choice, from your morning coffee to smoothies and juice. You can even shake it in a shaker for when you're on-the-go. Each scoop provides you with 10g of ultra-premium hydrolyzed collagen and is packed with amino acids.

On this product the quality and efficacy numbers were very high. Backed by scientific research, top-notch ingredients and a money-back guarantee, Primal Harvest's Primal Collagen is hands down the #1 collagen supplement of choice. 

It is super-affordable. Primal Collagen's pricing stands out, especially when you sign up for a subscription or buy multiple bags at once. Not only does this save you money and effort but since continued use over months is recommended to achieve the maximum benefits, signing up for a subscription is a no-brainer. It makes getting your daily collagen hassle-free, plus you never have to worry about running out halfway through the month. 

Click to Shop Now
Make a Smarter Choice

2. Collagen Peptides

by Vital Proteins

B+ Rating



Made in the USA

Gluten & Dairy-Free

Certified Grass-Fed Bovine Collagen Source

Easy To Use

Doesn't use hydrolyzed collagen

Unspecified collagen type

Click to Shop Now

372 votes


Ingredient Quality Control

Potency & Estimated Efficacy

Price / Customer Value

Return Policy

Overall Customer Happiness






Collagen Peptides by Vital Proteins is formulated with 20g of grass-fed and pasture-raised collagen. 

Like our number one choice, Primal Collagen by Primal Harvest, the Vital Proteins formula is easy to use. However, it falls into second place because they do not specify which type of collagen their Collagen Peptides contain. This may mean that it won't meet the needs of all consumers. 

Although this unflavored formula is a solid choice for a collagen, it was disappointing that it has a relatively high sodium content. This is definitely not ideal for those watching their sodium intake. It also makes the product less versatile. 

Additionally, this product is not certified as non-GMO. 

3. Multi Collagen Protein

by Ancient Nutrition

C+ Rating



Certified Grass-Fed Bovine Collagen 

Neutral Flavour

With probiotics  & vitamin C

Expensive Entry Price Point

Poor dissolvability into warm liquids

Click to Shop Now

567 votes


Ingredient Quality Control

Potency & Estimated Efficacy

Price / Customer Value

Return Policy

Overall Customer Happiness






Ancient Nutrition's Multi Collagen Protein is a pretty solid choice for a collagen supplement. It contains 10g of hydrolyzed collagen per scoop. Their collagen is sourced from grass-fed and pasture-raised bovine collagen, and like our top choice, is also non-GMO. 

We liked that it had a relatively neutral flavor which made it easier to drink when added to other beverages. Although it dissolved fairly easily into cold drinks, we still found that it took longer to dissolve than other collagen powders we tested. Many consumers also reported that it did not dissolve as easily into warm drinks. 

This would otherwise have been a great choice, but the pricing of this product knocks off a few points in our opinion. It’s a shame that this product has a pretty steep entry price point.

4. Super Youth Multi Collagen w/ Peptides

by SkinnyFit

C Rating



Variety of collagen types


Grass-fed & pasture-raised bovine and wild-caught fish collagen

Poor mixability

Click to Shop Now

937 votes


Ingredient Quality Control

Potency & Estimated Efficacy

Price / Customer Value

Return Policy

Overall Customer Happiness






Users complained of fishy flavor

SkinnyFit includes 7.8g of hydrolyzed collagen per scoop, sourced from grass-fed bovine collagen and fish collagen. The container consists of 58 servings of chocolate-cake flavored collagen powder. 

Although we liked that the formula includes a range of collagen types, many consumers found that the chocolate flavor was not enough to cover the fishy aftertaste of the fish collagen. We also found that the product did not dissolve as easily as the other products on this list and resulted in a clumpy liquid. Additionally, we enjoy the versatility of unflavored, neutral-tasting collagen peptide powders like that of our number one choice. We find that they are easier to implement into a regular daily routine as they can be added to any drink of choice. 

Another downside of this product was in its pricing as it had a high entry price point and many consumers complained that the product did not deliver the promised 58 servings.

5. Multi Collagen

by Renew

C Rating



Includes Multiple Types of Collagen

Diverse Amino Acid Profile

Made in the USA

Unpleasant Taste

Click to Shop Now

248 votes


Ingredient Quality Control

Potency & Estimated Efficacy

Price / Customer Value

Return Policy

Overall Customer Happiness






Doesn't Mix Well

Renew’s Multi Collagen peptide powder is formulated with hydrolyzed bovine collagen, hydrolyzed fish collagen, hydrolyzed chicken collagen, beef stock, and chicken egg membrane. Renew notes that their collagen powder is suitable for those following both Paleo and Keto diets. 

We liked that they included different types of collagen in their formula and that it has a wide amino acid profile.

However, both the taste and texture of this product were highly disappointing, despite being advertised as odorless and neutral in flavor. In fact, the flavor was very unpleasant, even when mixed with coffee and juices. It also had a chalky texture that did not dissolve well into liquid.

24-week Study on the Use Of Collagen Hydrolysate As a Dietary Supplement in Athletes with Activity-related Joint Pain

Kristine Clark-Wayne Sebastianelli-Klaus Flechsenhar-Douglas Aukermann-Felix Meza-Roberta Millard-John Deitch-Paul Sherbondy-Ann Albert - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18416885

Hydrolyzed Collagen Intake Increases Bone Mass Of Growing Rats Trained with Running Exercise

Satoko Takeda-Jong-Hoon Park-Eriko Kawashima-Ikuko Ezawa-Naomi Omi - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3750261/

Specific Collagen Peptides Improve Bone Mineral Density and Bone Markers in Postmenopausal Women-a Randomized Controlled Study

Daniel König-Steffen Oesser-Stephan Scharla-Denise Zdzieblik-Albert Gollhofer - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5793325/

Daily Consumption Of the Collagen Supplement Pure Gold Collagen® Reduces Visible Signs Of Aging

Maryam Borumand-Sara Sibilla - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4206255/

A Collagen Supplement Improves Skin Hydration, Elasticity, Roughness, and Density: Results Of a Randomized, Placebo-controlled, Blind Study

Liane Bolke-Gerrit Schlippe-Joachim Gerß-Werner Voss - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6835901/

Physiological Effects Of Dietary Amino Acids on Gut Health and Functions Of Swine

Zhongyue Yang-Shengfa Liao - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6579841/

Nutritional Factors and Hair Loss

D Rushton - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12190640

Decreased Collagen Production in Chronologically Aged Skin: Roles Of Age-dependent Alteration in Fibroblast Function and Defective Mechanical Stimulation

James Varani-Michael Dame-Laure Rittie-Suzanne Fligiel-Sewon Kang-Gary Fisher-John Voorhees - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1606623/

Hair Follicle Dermal Cells Regenerate the Dermal Sheath, Repopulate the Dermal Papilla, and Modulate Hair Type

Rahmani W;Abbasi S;Hagner A;Raharjo E;Kumar R;Hotta A;Magness S;Metzger D;Biernaskie J; - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25465495/

Amino Acid and Protein Metabolism During Exercise and Recovery

G Brooks - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3316914

Amino Acid and Protein Requirements: Cognitive Performance, Stress, and Brain Function

Institute of Medicine (US) Committee on Military Nutrition Research - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK224629/

Amino Acid Metabolism


Effects Of Amino Acid Supplementation on Muscle Soreness and Damage

Kazunori Nosaka-Paul Sacco-Kazunori Mawatari - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17342883


*These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA Food & Drug Administration. These products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. The information provided by this website or this company is not a substitute for a face-to-face consultation with your physician and should not be construed as individual medical advice. The testimonials on this website are individual cases and do not guarantee that you will get the same results. All content, including text, graphics, images and information, contained on or available through this web site is for general information purposes only.


Advertiser Disclosure

© 2022 Smarter-Choices.com. 
All Rights Reserved. 

Trademarks utilized on our website belong to their respective owners and no implied or expressed endorsement of our website or services is intended. Rankings can be affected by the relationship Smarter Choices has with our top picks.

[1] we have a financial relationship with some of our top picks and partners